By Kavita Mistry 
It was Zohran Mamdani’s campaign ad in Hindi with him explaining rank-choice voting in the Democratic primary for the New York City mayoral race that caught my attention earlier in the year.
Not to mention, he explained the electoral system using 3 cups of mango lassi!
While his electrifying media campaign has catapulted him, it was the background work that the campaign did that truly made me sit up – he started with talking to Trump voters instead of seeking approval of wealthy donors. The campaign is rewriting the playbook for how political entrepreneurs run for office in real-time.
The New York City mayoral race has provided a surprising but a much-needed inflection point in American politics. It seems to be architecting a generationally distinct political identity that could enrich political competition rooted in ideas for the future, a genuine desire to solve problems, and a commitment to build a stronger union that is much needed.
Mr. Mamdani’s victory in the primary and his most likely win in the general election will stand on the support of working class people – both young and middle-aged. His platform of affordability while holding on to his socio-political convictions directly challenges the politically baffling stance of his own party’s leadership. While American progressives (not “centrist” Democrats) have closed ranks behind Mr. Mamdani, surprisingly, on the affordability question, he has also captured some attention from significant representatives of the American right – Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene and Tucker Carlson, early MAGA (Make America Great Again) luminaries.
His messages of affordability seem to bring together the working class right and the left. The working class’s drift away from the established left started with the 2016 Presidential election (from being evenly split in 2012 to giving Mr. Trump a decisive edge). The gap narrowed somewhat in 2020 because of Joe Biden’s pro-labour image but widened again in 2024 against Kamala Harris. Senate minority leader Chuck Schumer once said that for every working class voter the Democratic Party loses, it gains two suburban, moderate Republicans; encapsulating this self-defeating drift
Focusing on the economic throughline, data from the Census and the Bureau of Labor Statistics show that since 2000, the American median income has grown only by 7%, while the consumer price index has jumped 60% – reflecting an entire generation of economic immobility. About 40% of children in the U.S. are born on Medicaid, the insurance programme for low-income families, meaning almost half of all the newborns start life in functional poverty. This has been the trend for at least a decade under both Democratic and Republican administrations.
Economic anxiety
The middle class is not faring any better. Massive college debt with no real employment prospects is crushing new and recent graduates. The aspirations of owning a home, starting families and someday retiring are fast fading into folklore. The resulting social dysfunction is manifesting in troubling ways among the youth – women are more educated and lean progressive whereas young men have increasingly lower college enrolment dampening their economic prospects and making them more vulnerable to extreme views and isolation.
Mr. Mamdani seems to have bucked this trend during the campaign. So, there may be some hope here to bring back young men into the political fold. But overall, there is an undercurrent coming to surface across political persuasions, religious and racial identities, and everything else that political systems use to divide people. And that undercurrent is of economic anxiety. The broader economic structure is increasingly seen as oligarchic by most working class people and is giving room for someone like Mr. Mamdani, who identifies himself as a Democratic Socialist. Senator Bernie Sanders and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez have had a strong showing of their oligarchy tour even in Republican States.
Voter discontent
A recent Washington Post-ABC poll shows 7 out of 10 Americans say Democrats are “out-of-touch”, but also shows 6 out of 10 Americans feel the same way about Republicans and President Donald Trump; expect political insurgents on both sides. Tying this back to the New York City race, while rent control and free buses may be local issues, the broader affordability theme it underscores is inescapable. We could see an interesting convergence among Republicans and Democrats when it comes to the issue of affordability.
The administration’s attempts to resurrect the decimated working class has manifested in unstable tariff prescriptions making middle-class small businesses (accounting for 40% of GDP) and their employees (constituting 46% of the labour force) especially vulnerable. The Presidential election may have indeed been run on immigration and “woke” issues, but cultural polarisation is now getting superseded by the financial fragility of American families. With the U.S. Congress deadlocked on government funding, these economic anxieties are only rising.
One thing, however, is getting clear—the one word that pundits and the broader political ecosystem avoids like the plague is increasingly the lens through which to see things—class. The margin of Mr. Mamdani’s victory on Tuesday will mark an important milestone in this imminent re-architecting of American political thinking.
Rohit Tripathi is Principal at VU Capital (Strategy Consulting)